Value

How to find out what old coins are worth

Someone may already have given you a number: the silver in the box, a price-guide screenshot, or a same-day offer to “take it all.” Those aren’t the same thing. Here’s how to tell them apart.

The short answer

Old coins have two kinds of value. Melt value is the metal in the coin at today’s price. Collector value is what someone will pay for the coin itself, based on date, mint mark, condition, and whether a set is complete. Price guides and phone apps are not offers. The number you can trust is a written offer, and you want more than one, on the same list of coins.

A tray of Liberty Head $20 gold coins
Liberty Head $20 gold coins. Photo: Brian Boltryk

Start with two different numbers

Melt value is the silver or gold in a coin times today’s metal price. It’s a floor, not a selling price, and not an appraisal.

Collector value is what someone will pay because of the date, the mint mark, the condition, and whether a set is still complete in its original packaging. For most worn, common coins, the two numbers sit close together. What you’re looking for are the exceptions, and that’s why you list the coins before anyone quotes a price for the whole lot.

What’s usually in the box

A typical inherited box is a mix: not a hidden fortune, and not “just face value.” Expect older silver coins, maybe some silver dollars, government proof and mint sets, a jar of old cents, and now and then a gold coin or a coin in a sealed plastic holder. Most of it is common. A few pieces may deserve a closer look, and those are the ones that get lost when everything is sold as one lot.

Anything that might be gold

Even common gold coins pack a lot of value into a small space. If anything might be gold, keep it separate and have it identified in person before anyone makes an offer. If a gold-colored coin is marked “COPY,” don’t assume anything.

A tray of $2.50 gold quarter eagles
Small $2.50 gold quarter eagles. Photo: Brian Boltryk

How to get a number you can trust

Price-guide pages and app “grades” aren’t offers. They often show what dealers ask for coins that are already certified, which isn’t what a buyer will pay you for coins straight out of a drawer.

The number that counts is a written, itemized offer. Get two or three on the same list, and tell buyers up front that you’re comparing. A jewelry counter or pawn shop is usually a poor first stop, because those counters are set up to buy metal, not to sort out the better coins.

Is it worth getting coins graded?

Usually not. Grading costs money, plus insured shipping and a wait, and it only pays off for coins that are collectible and in good condition. Worn common silver almost never qualifies. And if you need a formal value for an estate, that’s a written appraisal from an independent professional, which is a different thing from an offer.

Your next step

Know what you have before anyone makes an offer

The Kit takes you from “a box of old coins” to a clear, photographed list with melt values worked out and written offers compared side by side. No coin knowledge needed.

Cover of Inherited Coin Collection Kit

Inherited Coin Collection Kit

  • A 39-page illustrated guide that walks you through the whole box, start to finish
  • An inventory workbook with a melt-value calculator and an offer comparison tab
  • How to check out a dealer and get 2–3 written offers, with short, polite scripts
  • The printable “7 Things First” checklist

30-day refund: if it doesn’t help you, email within 30 days for a full refund.

Lots of silver dollars? The Heir’s Bundle ($29) adds the Silver Dollars Guide to the Kit.

Not ready to buy? Start with the free “7 Things First” checklist: one page for the first 48 hours.

Get it free

Questions

How do I find out what my old coins are worth?

Make a list, work out the melt value of any silver or gold, and get two or three written offers on the same list. The Kit walks you through each step.

What is melt value?

The value of the metal in a coin at today’s price. It’s a floor, not a selling price.

Are coins from before 1965 worth anything?

U.S. dimes, quarters, and half dollars dated 1964 and earlier are 90% silver, so they’re worth at least their silver. Some dates and high-condition coins are worth more.

Can a coin app tell me what my coin is worth?

Not reliably. Apps and price guides aren’t offers. Use them as a starting point, then get written offers from reputable buyers.

Brian Boltryk is a rare coin trader with more than ten years of experience. He has handled estates and many large gold and silver deals, and writes plain-English guides for families who inherit coins. More about Brian

Educational only, not tax, legal, or financial advice. This isn’t an appraisal, a price guarantee, or an offer to buy or sell. Coin values change daily. The views are the author’s own.

Inherited coins? The step-by-step Kit, $19.

See it · $19